Student Conduct Committee to hear Knights case, after Junior Dean finds no hazing

The Junior Dean ended his investigation into the hazing allegations

The Student Conduct and Capacity Committee looks set to consider the case against the Knights of the Campanile following the Junior Dean’s dismissal of hazing allegations.

Speaking to Trinity News, Editor of the University Times Eleanor O’Mahony said: “Essentially, the Junior Dean closed the investigation without speaking to us about it and without asking for evidence despite knowing we had ample evidence – a recording of the hazing – to assist with his investigation.”

“As far as we are concerned, he did not follow proper processes,” she continued. “The matter will be considered by the committee.”

The Junior Dean, Tim Trimble, ended the investigation into the Knights of the Campanile earlier this month, stating he “found only that an unauthorized party was convened in [Ben Arrowsmith’s, Knights of the Campanile President] apartment on 27th February” in emails seen by Trinity News.

The Junior Dean confirmed to Arrowsmith on April 5 that he had “not reopened this investigation”.

Speaking to Trinity News on the investigation being brought to the committee, the Knights of the Campanile said: “The Knights perspective on the controversy created by the irresponsible behaviour of the University Times and its Editor is provided in the ‘notices to members’ on our website. And, with the Junior Dean confirming his investigation re the Knights has concluded and won’t be reopened, we have nothing further to add.”

The role of the Student Conduct and Capacity Committee is to “to hear, determine and resolve certain cases relating to student conduct and capacity,” as outlined in the College statutes.

The committee comprises the College Registrar, or a nominee of the Registrar, and twenty additional members. Members are to consist “so far as possible of eight members of the academic staff, four undergraduate students, four graduate students, and four members of the technical, administrative and support staff”. Any given hearing may include seven members of the committee, with a quorum of five, of which at least one must be a student.

The investigation emerged following an article published by the University Times entitled “Knights of the Campanile Implicated in On-Campus Hazing Evening” which alleged that “groaning, gagging, and retching sounds” came from the apartment where the Knights were gathering and that members were told to “bend over” and “get in the shower”.

The article received backlash from students after its publication, which detailed that UT reporters stood outside Arrowsmith’s apartment in House 37 where they heard “shouted instructions,” before placing a recording device outside the apartment door and waiting upstairs “out of sight for over an hour and a half”.

The Knights denied that any “humiliation and/or bullying” took place during the evening in a letter signed by the society’s Master, Peter Ledbetter. The letter criticised UT’s reporting methods as having “disturbing implications for the privacy rights of all students in College”.

In an interview with Trinity News, Arrowsmith refuted University Times’ reporting of the February 27 party. “I suppose they [UT] picked up over the course of 80 odd minutes, I think they printed something like 44 words, so a very small number of snatches of conversation which they then went on to fairly irresponsibly report completely out of context.”

“Telling someone to bend over for instance, they’re painting it in a completely, I’m not going to say irrelevant, but decontextualised light insofar as that was one particularly tall guy being asked to bend over when he was putting on a bike helmet,” he said.

Arrowsmith continued: “Anything along the lines of bullying or humiliation is not something I personally or the Knights as a society stand by or stand for. It’s never been of part my time, or I’m pretty sure before that. It’s never been a part of any activities we’ve undertaken and it’s something we strongly condemn obviously.”

Today is the last day of voting in a referendum to dramatically decrease UT’s funding, after Trinity College Dublin Students’ Union (TCDSU) received 500 signatures, the necessary number to trigger a referendum.

If the referendum passes, the UT Editor’s salary and accommodation is set to be cut, while the union’s funding for the newspaper would be reduced to €3,000 a year.

The “Save UT, Vote No” campaign released a statement this morning, outlining: “Given the incomplete nature of the investigation, the Student Conduct and Capacity Committee, a disciplinary board in Trinity that operates at a level above the Junior Dean, will hold a full hearing on the issue. The committee will listen to the recording and other evidence of the evening before coming to a conclusion.”

Additionally, the campaign alleged it had “been been made aware of a number of cynical, misleading messages circulating within WhatsApp groups in relation to this referendum”.

The campaign pointed to “messages state that this referendum will put UT’s funding on a par with that of TN [Trinity News]” and outlined these were “not true”.

The campaign said: “Last year, TN received more than €20,000, and the TN Editor also receives either a monthly stipend or paid accommodation.”

Trinity News received €11,728 towards print costs for the 2017/18 academic year, alongside accommodation for the editor which amounts to approximately €8,000 each year.

The Electoral Commission circulated a statement this morning, explaining: “It has been brought to our attention that there has been a circulation of false statements in regard to the Referenda. While this is out of our control we would wish to remind all students of the college’s Dignity and Respect Policy.”

Lauren Boland

Lauren Boland was the Editor of the 67th volume of Trinity News. She is an English Literature and Sociology graduate and previously served as Deputy Editor, News Editor and Assistant News Editor.